German Court Bans Health Card Seizure Over Unpaid Insurance, June 18

Germany’s Bavarian State Social Court ruled on June 18 that health insurance companies cannot seize or block electronic health cards from people who fall behind on premium payments. The court found no legal basis for the practice, which affects millions of insured Germans. The decision overturns a common industry approach used by multiple insurers to enforce payment collection.

What the Court Decided

The Bavarian Regional Social Court (LSG) issued its ruling on May 19, 2026, and made it public on June 18. The court stated that health insurers cannot seize or block electronic health cards simply because a member owes back premiums. The court found that no law permits this action. Every insured person has a legal right to receive an electronic health card under German law, regardless of payment status.

How Payment Delays Work Under German Law

When an insured person falls two months behind on premiums despite a warning notice, their benefits pause. During this pause, the insurer still covers acute illnesses, pain treatment, pregnancy care, and preventive screenings. All other services stop. The law allows this pause but does not permit the insurer to take away the card itself. The court clarified that card seizure lacks any legal foundation.

Why Insurers Took This Step

Since the electronic health card became mandatory on January 1, 2015, the system cannot technically mark a pause on the card itself. To work around this gap, many insurers seized the card and gave people paper vouchers instead. These vouchers only cover specific services like home care and rehabilitation, not doctor or dental visits. The court rejected this workaround as improper.

What Happens Next

The court said insurers can electronically mark a pause on the card to prevent misuse. This is the only legal way to handle the situation. The ruling is not yet final and can be appealed. The decision applies to millions of German insured people and signals that the widespread practice must stop.

Final Thoughts

Insurers must stop seizing health cards from people with unpaid premiums. The court’s ruling closes a loophole that affected millions of Germans and forces the industry to use electronic marking instead of card seizure.

FAQs

Disclaimer:

The content shared by Meyka AI PTY LTD is solely for research and informational purposes.  Meyka is not a financial advisory service, and the information provided should not be considered investment or trading advice.